HomeIndiaGovt sending back names...

Govt sending back names reiterated by Collegium matter of concern: SC




STATE TIMES NEWS

New Delhi: The Supreme Court said on Friday it is a “matter of concern” that the government is sending back the names reiterated by the Collegium for judgeship in constitutional courts despite there being nothing in the present scenario to prevent the appointment post reiteration.
A bench of Justices S K Kaul and A S Oka observed that nothing prevents the legislature from bringing in a better system for appointment of judges to constitutional courts but till the time the law holds it must be implemented.
Advocate Prashant Bhushan, appearing for one of the petitioners, said even the names reiterated by the Collegium have been sent back by the government
“That is a matter of concern. We have already flagged it in the last order,” said the bench, which was hearing a matter related to the alleged delay by the Centre in clearing the names recommended by the Collegium for appointment as judges to the Supreme Court and high courts.
It said the government may have its own views when a recommendation is made but it can’t be kept on hold without sending back the comments on it.
“What is to be done is that comments can be sent to us. We will look into the comments, see whether we want to reiterate it or drop the name. If we reiterate the name, then there is, as per the present scenario, nothing which can prevent the appointment,” it said.
The bench said every system has its positives and negatives and neither anyone is saying that there is a perfect system nor can there be a perfect system.
Justice Kaul observed the grave concern is, “are we creating an environment where meritorious people have hesitancy in giving their consent (for judgeship). It is happening. I have seen it happening.”
The bench said the delay in clearing the names deter people from giving consent.
When the bench asked Attorney General R Venkataramani about the five names recommended by the collegium last month for elevation as judges of the apex court, he requested the court to defer it, saying he is looking into the matter.
“This should not take time. They are already existing chief justices and senior judges,” Justice Kaul said.
The bench also observed, “If you look at the statements made in the parliament and otherwise, the court itself at times has considered the view of the government and dropped names. That has also happened.”
The top court said it is not that every name recommended by the high court’s Collegium goes through and this shows the scrutiny.
It said there are people with different points of view and a court must reflect different philosophy and course of views.
“I do believe when you join as a judge… you are here to do a job and trained yourself to do a job independently, dehors (other than, not including or outside the scope of) whatever may have been your political affiliations, what may have been the thought processes,” Justice Kaul said.
He said there is a spectrum of thought process in appointment of judges and if a person has his or her own thought process, it does not mean he or she is aligned one way or the other. “Integrity of course is the first qualification,” the bench said.


Most Popular

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

More from Author

This Cancer Drug Can Increase Longevity, Study Finds

A new study has found that a particular cancer drug has...

American Heart Association Reports Largest Increase In Cardiovascular-Related Deaths

A recent report by the American Heart Association has found that...

Ants Can Detect Cancer Tumors In Urine, Scientists Find

Move over dogs, ants are the new olfactory superheroes. A new...

74th Indian Republic Day Parade 2023 – All You Need To Know

Building on last year’s celebrations, in the 75th year of Independence,...

Read Now

This Cancer Drug Can Increase Longevity, Study Finds

A new study has found that a particular cancer drug has the ability to extend life span. The finding is a shot in the arm for the scientists racing against time.The study, published in the journal Nature Aging, showed that long-term treatment of healthy mice from middle...

American Heart Association Reports Largest Increase In Cardiovascular-Related Deaths

A recent report by the American Heart Association has found that the COVID-19 pandemic indirectly led to the largest increase in cardiovascular-related deaths in the U.S.The data report, published Wednesday in the journal Circulation, found that 2020, the first year of the pandemic, saw the most number...

Ants Can Detect Cancer Tumors In Urine, Scientists Find

Move over dogs, ants are the new olfactory superheroes. A new study has found that ants can "sniff out" cancer tumors in urine samples.The study, published in the journal Proceedings of the Royal Society B, found that ants’ sense of smell is so strong that they can detect...

74th Indian Republic Day Parade 2023 – All You Need To Know

Building on last year’s celebrations, in the 75th year of Independence, celebrated as ‘Azadi ka Amrit Mahotsav’, the Republic Day celebration this year shall witness zeal, enthusiasm, patriotic fervour, and ‘Jan Bhagidari’, as envisioned by Prime Minister Narendra Modi. President Droupadi Murmu will lead the Nation in celebrating...

Here’s What A High-Fat Diet Does To The Brain

Fatty foods taste so good. There’s no denying it. But there’s a new reason to avoid it since according to a recent study, a high-fat diet leads to more food intake and weight gain. Scientists from Penn State College of Medicine reported in their study published in The...

Updated Boosters Lower COVID-19 Risk By Half: CDC

The updated COVID-19 vaccine boosters are very dependable when it comes to preventing the disease, with new data showing they cut the risk of getting sick from the coronavirus by about half. The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) published new studies on the bivalent boosters this...

Constitution makers’ vision guiding our Republic: Prez Murmu

STATE TIMES NEWS NEW DELHI: Founders of the Constitution gave us a map and moral framework, the task of “walking that path remains our...

Digital currency to further bolster digital economy, says RBI

CHANDIGARH: Digital currency will further bolster the digital economy, make payment system more efficient, reduce cost involved in physical cash management and also...

Multi-layer security cover in Delhi for Republic Day celebrations

NEW DELHI: A multi-layer security cover has been put in place ahead of Republic Day celebrations in the national capital to thwart any...

Main shooter behind grenade attack on Punjab Police intelligence HQ arrested: NIA

NEW DELHI: A terror operative who was the main shooter in the grenade attack on the Punjab Police intelligence headquarters in Mohali last...

26 unsung heroes honoured with Padma awards

NEW DELHI: Medical professional Dilip Mahalanabis, who returned from the US to serve in 1971-Bangladesh war refugee camps and promoted world wide use...